The True Meaning of Patriotism
How language shapes loyalty, identity, and the boundaries of belonging.
📌 Introduction
Patriotism. A word that evokes powerful emotions and images—flags, anthems, and pledges of allegiance. It’s a concept often invoked to inspire unity but also easily exploited to divide and exclude.
From political speeches to marketing campaigns, patriotism is constantly redefined to fit particular agendas. But what does it indeed mean? And how does the language of patriotism shape our understanding of loyalty, identity, and belonging?
This edition of the True Meaning Series dissects how patriotism is constructed, manipulated, and weaponised through words.
🔍 What It Says vs. What It Means
Analysing common expressions and symbols of patriotism:
🇺🇸 Loyalty to the Nation
What it says: Unwavering dedication to one’s country.
What it means: Often exploited to demand conformity and suppress dissent.
🎖️ Support Our Troops
What it says: Respect and solidarity for those serving in the military.
What it means: Used to justify military actions and shut down criticism of government policies.
🏳️ National Pride
What it says: Celebrating one’s heritage and culture.
What it means: It can be manipulated to promote exclusionary or supremacist ideologies.
🦄 American Exceptionalism (or National Exceptionalism)
What it says: The belief that one’s nation is unique or superior.
What it means: A narrative often used to rationalise imperialism, xenophobia, or othering.
🦅 Case Study: The Proud Boys—Patriotism as a Tool for Division
The Proud Boys emerged in the United States as a far-right group appropriating patriotic symbols to justify violence, white supremacy, and anti-democratic actions under the guise of defending American ideals. Their use of symbols like the American flag and slogans such as “Make America Great Again” (MAGA) reflects a distorted version of patriotism rooted in exclusion rather than unity.
Their rhetoric positions them as defenders of 'traditional' values, but the reality is a movement steeped in nostalgia for a mythologised past that excludes marginalised groups. By cloaking xenophobia, racism, and misogyny in the language of patriotism, the Proud Boys demonstrate how the term can be weaponised to divide rather than unite.
🏛️ The Semiotics of Patriotism
Patriotism is a semiotic construct built on symbols, rituals, and narratives. However, the meanings of these symbols are rarely static. They are contested, co-opted, and weaponised. Here’s how:
🚩 Flags as Symbols of Control and Rebellion
The American flag, for example, is both a symbol of unity and a tool of exclusion. When draped around the shoulders of insurrectionists at the Capitol riot, it becomes a paradoxical icon used to justify rebellion against authority and allegiance to it.
🛡️ Appropriation of Cultural Symbols
The Proud Boys’ adoption of 'patriotic' symbols such as the American flag or slogans like “Make America Great Again” reflects how extremist groups exploit the language of patriotism to legitimise exclusion and aggression.
🏅 Hero Narratives
Phrases like “Support Our Troops” or “Defend the Homeland” create simplified binaries of loyalty and betrayal. They are often used to discredit dissenters as unpatriotic, mainly when those dissenters belong to marginalised communities.
📜 National Myths
The narrative of American Exceptionalism is rooted in myth-making. It frames the U.S. as a beacon of freedom, conveniently ignoring historical and ongoing injustices.
⚖️ Purity Codes
'True patriotism' is often framed in exclusionary ways—through racial, religious, or ideological purity. Groups like the Proud Boys exploit these purity codes to define who belongs and who doesn’t.
⚡ The Impact of Patriotism Speak
The language of patriotism has both positive and negative consequences. But the negatives are often ignored or brushed aside. Here’s a deeper dive:
✅ Positive Impacts
📌 Fosters a sense of belonging, community, and shared purpose.
📌 Encourages civic participation and collective resilience.
📌 Can inspire progressive change when directed toward justice and equity.
❌ Negative Impacts
📌 Exclusionary Nationalism: Framing patriotism through exclusionary narratives leads to xenophobia, racism, and cultural erasure.
📌 Silencing Dissent: Patriotism speak is often weaponised to suppress criticism, delegitimise social movements, and label dissenters as traitors.
📌 Cultural Co-optation: Groups like the Proud Boys redefine patriotism to serve extremist agendas, giving legitimacy to hate and violence under the guise of defending national values.
📌 Selective Memory: National pride is often built on mythologised history, glossing over oppression, exploitation, and injustice.
📌 Mentality of Exceptionalism: Promotes an 'us vs. them' worldview that justifies aggression and dominance over perceived outsiders.
For patriotism to have a true meaning, it must be rooted in inclusivity, justice, and a commitment to progress.
💡 Actionable Insights
🔍 Reframe Patriotism
Challenge the narrow definitions of patriotism that promote exclusion. Advocate for a pluralistic, inclusive understanding of loyalty to one's country.
🗣️ Encourage Critical Loyalty
Genuine patriotism involves holding one’s country accountable and striving for a better society.
🗽 Principled Belonging
Embrace a sense of loyalty rooted in principles and values rather than political views and mythologies. True patriotism thrives when grounded in ethical standards that transcend transient political agendas.
📖 Deconstruct Symbols
Recognise how extremist groups manipulate symbols of patriotism and reclaim them for inclusive purposes.
🤝 Embrace Multicultural Narratives
Expand the national narrative to include all groups, not just the dominant ones.
🌍 Humanity Over Nationality
Patriotism often insists on allegiance to a particular nation-state, but what happens when that loyalty conflicts with universal human rights and empathy? The phrase 'Humanity Over Nationality' invites us to reconsider our primary loyalty—should it be to a flag or the shared dignity of all people?
It challenges the exclusionary aspects of patriotism by encouraging us to prioritise ethical principles over tribal affiliations. True patriotism should not require sacrificing compassion, justice, or our shared humanity. Instead, it should enhance these values.
🎤 Conclusion
Patriotism can be a force for unity or a tool of division. Understanding how language constructs patriotism helps us determine whether it inspires positive change or reinforces exclusionary ideologies.
For patriotism to have a true meaning, it must be rooted in inclusivity, justice, and a commitment to progress.
🚀 If you enjoyed this edition of the True Meaning Series, consider becoming a paid subscriber. Gain access to deeper insights, exclusive content, and a growing community of critical thinkers who challenge the narratives shaping our world. Subscribe today and be part of the conversation!
